Main Menu

Battery Storage vs Generators

Which Is the Better Option?
Reach out To Learn More

Battery Storage vs Backup Generators

With utility companies becoming more expensive and unpredictable, having a reliable backup power source is more important than ever. Whether you’re a homeowner looking to keep the lights on during a storm or a business needing to ensure uninterrupted operations, choosing the right backup power solution is essential.

The two most popular options are battery storage systems and traditional generators. Which one is better? Below, we’ll explore the differences between the two, ultimately showing why battery storage is the best choice for your peace of mind.

How Battery Storage Works vs. How Generators Work

Battery Storage

Battery storage systems prepare you for the next planned or unplanned power outage, huge storm, or managing a utility company’s peak times by storing energy from the grid or renewable sources like solar panels. You lower your electricity bills, and earn money through grid services like net metering. The transition to backup power is instant and seamless, with minimal energy loss.

Generators

Generators, on the other hand, burn fuel to generate electricity. They start up when the power goes out, usually after a brief delay. This process is less efficient, with energy lost during fuel conversion, and requires a continuous fuel supply to operate during outages.

Efficiency and Sustainability

solar power system

Efficiency

Battery storage systems are efficient and cost-effective. They store energy during off-peak times or when renewable sources like solar panels generate excess power. This stored energy is then used when needed. Battery storage ensures that nearly all the energy captured is utilized, making it a reliable and cleaner choice.

 

Generators, however, rely on burning fossil fuels to generate electricity, which is inherently less efficient. The combustion process leads to significant energy loss through heat and emissions. Generators operate at lower efficiency rates, meaning much fuel consumed is not converted into usable electricity. This inefficiency, combined with the need for continuous operation during outages, results in higher fuel consumption and greater environmental impact.

Sustainability

As touched on above, battery storage systems are the more sustainable choice. They produce no emissions, reducing a home’s environmental impact. Generators, however, rely on fossil fuels, contributing to pollution.

Cost Savings of Battery Storage over a Generator

Upfront Costs

Battery storage systems typically have a higher upfront cost due to the investment in advanced batteries. However, this is balanced by lower long-term costs (see below). And, don’t forget, the Federal IRA incentives will help offset your installation bill. In Colorado, there are further incentives to take advantage of. We can help you navigate all of your savings.

Long-term Costs

Battery storage requires little maintenance and no fuel, reducing ongoing expenses. Generators, while cheaper initially, incur significant costs for fuel, maintenance, and repairs. Also, when you pair your battery with solar, you are reducing your electricity bills. You can even control your usage during a utilities peak demand time by moving to your battery storage to keep from paying peak fees.

Enphase Panel

Durability and Lifespan

EV Car Charging in Garage

Battery Storage is more Durable and Longer Lasting

Battery storage not only lasts 10-15 years with minimal degradation, they can handle thousands of charge and discharge cycles. You will be able to rely on your battery for planned blackouts, unexpected storms and demand management.

Generators typically have a shorter lifespan, averaging 5-10 years. They require frequent maintenance, including oil changes and fuel system checks. Over time, mechanical wear can lead to inefficiencies and breakdowns, making them less durable and dirtier than a modern battery system.

Safety Consderations

Which is Safer?

Battery storage systems are designed with modern safety features like thermal management and automatic shut-off to prevent accidents. These features make them safer for both residential and commercial use.

Generators, on the other hand, pose several risks, including the potential for fires and carbon monoxide poisoning. Proper ventilation and maintenance are essential, but even with precautions, generators are not the safer option.

Performance During Power Outages

Performance Matters When The Power's Out

During power outages, battery storage provide instant backup power. These systems kick in immediately when the grid fails, so there’s no disruption to what matters most such as medical equipment, home security, and refrigeration.

Generators, however, often experience a delay before they start supplying power, leading to  disruptions. When you rely on critical items like medical devices, you can not afford to have a delay. Since generators require fuel to operate, they become less reliable if there becomes a fuel shortage or access to fuel is not available.

Next Steps to Power Up

As you can see, battery storage is the way to go when you’re concerned about keeping your home or business charged during power outages. We have expertise to help you choose the right system for your needs, and we will help you understand the incentives available to you. 

Reach out today to learn more!

Google Logo Five Stars

Read What People Have To Say About Us!

Independent Power
Excellent
4.8
Based on 265 reviews
Brian and tj were very professional and had great customer service. They knew exactly what they were doing and are very knowledgeable of the equipment. What they installed works flawlessly and they left the site spotless
Response from the owner: Thank you for the great 5-star review, Cristi! TJ and Brian are great guys. Not only do they know their stuff, they also genuinely care about our customers. Thanks for choosing to work with us; we appreciate you! Please let us know if we can be of service in the future.
Josh and team installed my home charger and did a great job! They were communicative and friendly, highly recommend and would use again! Thank you!
Response from the owner: Thank you for the 5-star review, Kelsey! We appreciate the shout-out to Josh and our team. We're lucky to have them on our team because not only are they professionals, they also care about helping people out. And congrats on your new charger! Your EV is going to be charged in record time now.Thanks again, please let us know if we can be of service in the future.
Josh did a great job installing our EV charger and some other electrical in our garage. Highly recommend.
Response from the owner: Thanks for the 5-star review, Dave! Josh is a masterful electrician, and we're happy he's part of our team. And, it's exciting to hear you've installed an EV Charger; you're vehicle will be juiced up in lightning speed now. Thanks again for the wonderful review. Please let us know if we can be of service in the future.
I wanted to expand my solar system and my previous provider was totally non-responsive. I found Independent Power when I was biding out the expansion. They have been very professional and timely throughout the entire process. They were able to integrate my old system into the new one with a powerwall. This is a quality contractor!! I would highly recommend them.
Response from the owner: Thank you for the 5-star review, Michael! How exciting that you expanded your solar and added battery storage. We love helping our customers gain energy independence, and we sure appreciate you taking the time to leave a detailed comment. Please let us know if we can be of service in the future!
Josh is amazing and we're grateful for being able to find him through Independent Power! He's been our go to guy for all of our electrical needs. I've used a lot of local electricians, trying to find the right company and people to service our needs. I had zero luck finding this until I got fed up with reaching out to my electricians for a follow up and started searching for another company and found Indepent Power.We are always blown away by his ability to meet the needs of our residents and company. He's always got a smile on his face, super easy to reach and very responsive. This is one of a few reasons I choose to use Independent Power for our needs. I would highly suggest them to anyone looking for an electrician. Very resonable prices, great customer service, the best at following up and always do a wonderful job. I wouldn't go with another company. They are simply the best!
Response from the owner: Wow, Melissa, thank you for this incredible 5-star review! Josh is truly a great guy that happens to be the best electrician. It's wonderful to hear how he's helped you and your residents out. We are lucky to have him as part of the Independent Power team. We appreciate you taking the time to leave a review and share your feedback. Please let us know if we can be of service in the future.
Dakota was communicative and on time. Always very helpful and respectful.
Response from the owner: Thanks for the 5-star review, Matt! Dakota is the best. His priority has always been our customers. His expertise in the HVAC field allows him to help people with everything from service to installation. We're lucky to have him on our team. We appreciate you taking the time to recognize Dakota!
Jan repaired our computer that runs our solar power. She was fast professional and knew what she was doing. I give her 5 stars
Response from the owner: Thank you for the 5-star review, Bruce. We're lucky to have Jan as part of the crew. She's passionate about helping customers, and about solar for everyone. We sure appreciate you and hope we can be of service in the future.
Independent Power finished the installation of our cold-climate heat pump on January 6, just about a week before the super cold, sub-zero temperatures hit. We knew it was going to be the first big test of the system, and I'm happy to say that it came through with flying colors! Our house stayed nice and toasty throughout the cold snap. We still have a gas furnace for part of the house, but we didn't even think of firing it up because we never needed it. Really impressed with the system's performance over the cold snap and in its first month of operation!Now a few words about the Company itself. My understanding is that IPS hasn't been doing heat pump installations all that long, but that they hired people with lots of previous heat pump installation experience. It sure seemed that way to me--the crew that installed our system, which was fairly complex, was really professional, highly skilled, and very responsive to my questions and requests. I gotta say, I was impressed with how quickly and efficiently the team worked.As I mentioned, our system is rather complex: part of it (our lower level and upper level) uses existing ductwork, and the other part (living room, kitchen, dining room) uses wall units. Based on my request, they installed the refrigerant lines in such a way that they are completely hidden. Originally the estimator had specified a route for the lines that would have had a lot of the lines outside the house and also would have required them to punch holes in the ceiling every few feet (which we would then need to repair at added cost). They accommodated my request for the alternate route, which made for a more difficult installation, but a much cleaner one.Another thing I'll mention is that the crew was very careful about cleaning up after themselves at the end of every day. They were all very polite and answered a lot of questions that I and my wife had. Definitely high marks for customer support!We needed an electrical upgrade to handle the extra power draw of the heat pump. The electrician came out in advance of the install to scope out the existing panel and plan the work. He told me exactly where he was going to run the lines and the new grounding system that we needed. His work was very clean and exactly as specified. Extra added bonus: now every breaker has a label describing the circuit that it serves! Plus, we now have a lot of extra capacity for any new loads in the future.I will say that there is a small learning curve with heat pumps. The working fluid doesn't get nearly as hot as a gas flame, so the system uses a slower fan speed and less air flow than a gas furnace. That means that it takes these systems longer to come up to a set point than a conventional furnace. So if you use a nighttime setback temperature, you probably don't want to let it drop as far as you did with your furnace because it will take longer to come back up to your desired temp in the morning. Even so, we've found that we can use a nighttime temp of 62 and unless it's brutally cold outside, the house is usually back up to 70 by the time we come downstairs around 7 am. Also, the user guide that comes with the Mitsubishi wall units leaves a lot to be desired. It can take a while to understand how to control the wall units so they perform the way you want, but we got the hang of it in a couple weeks.All in all, I'm a very satisfied customer and would strongly recommend IPS for your heat pump installation!
Response from the owner: Wow, Dan! We are so grateful for this 5-star review. Your level of detailed explanation on how the install went and the performance of your Mitsubishi heat pump system will help people who are considering a heat pump system what to expect from a system and what it's like to work with our team. It's exciting to see the Colorado Community making the switch to energy-efficient heat pumps and we love being a part of the movement.Please let us know if we may be of service for your future electrification/renewable energy projects.
A+ install experience for a 200A panel upgrade, heat pump, and mini split install. It's rare for a company to have both a stellar HVAC and electrical team. I'll absolutely be looking to Independent for future electrification jobs.
Response from the owner: Thank you for the 5-star review, Riley! We love helping our community switch to heat pumps and designing a system perfect for your needs. We'd be excited to help you with any projects you may have in the future.
TJ did a superb job. He was professional, courteous, and highly knowledgeable. He made sure everything was in working order before he left, and he was available for any questions I had on the new system. I highly recommend him and Independent Power to anyone looking for mini split installs!
Response from the owner: Thank you for the 5-star review, Kirsten! We sure appreciate the shout-out to TJ, we're lucky to have him on our team. And, we're excited that you installed a heat pump system! You will love the comfort they bring to your home. Please let us know if we can be of service in the future.
js_loader
Independent Power
4.8
Based on 265 reviews
×
js_loader